Wisdom Wednesday – Troublemakers vs. Incompetents

When I worked at Southeast Regional Library, it was often a struggle to find decent branch librarians in many of the small towns where we operated.

A mixture of a limited pool of potential employees, competition from other businesses in terms of pay and hours (there may not be many other employers depending on the size of the town. But where there were, they often offered more hours than the 10-25 the public library was open each week.)

The skillsets of many applicants weren’t always a great match for public library work – a retired teacher was usually a great fit but a farmer’s wife looking to supplement their meagre income could be an issue (case in point: me having to have a tough conversation with one local librarian who regularly came to work straight from cleaning their barn, prompting complaints from locals that reached HQ and led to the Branch Supervisor making a special trip out to the community to address it directly!)

Retirement party for long-time local librarian also shows the typical make-up of a small town library’s staff and board!

(Side note: idea for future blog post on how having well-established, “trust-based, truth-telling” relationships – as a former RPL HR manager called it – is so vital to any type of supervisory/management work.  In many ways, it might be the single most important but under-valued skill in management.)

Anyhow, we had hired a new branch librarian in one of our communities who hit many of our sweet spots – studying at University, hard-working, known in the community,  good match of availiabity and the branch’s hours, tech-savvy, creative ideas, etc. etc.

So I was *very* surprised when my Director came to me about five months after she was hired to say “I need you have a probationary meeting with her and tell her she didn’t pass.”

Wait – what?  WHAT?

“Uhm, she’s doing really well.  What do you mean?”

“She’s a troublemaker.”

Now, this was one thing that was a potential issue.  I didn’t think of it as being a “troublemaker” but I did see how she advocated strongly for herself – wondering why she didn’t get paid for her required role as “volunteer” secretary for the board, asking to be paid double-time for work she did on a holiday representing the library (Canada Day parade maybe?) and other inquiries like that.

“But she’s really good.”

“She asks too many questions.  We don’t have time to deal with someone that time-consuming.”

“We have half a dozen branch librarians who are borderline incompetent including some who’ve been in their jobs for over a decade.  Why would we let someone who’s doing great in basically every area go.”

I didn’t argue with my boss too often (hard to believe but I was young, new and learning, and generally saw his point of view and 30+ years of working in libraries.) but I pushed back pretty hard on this as I just couldn’t see his logic of pushing someone away who was already making her local library much better than it had been.

I didn’t win the argument but maybe it was a draw because he came back a day later after asking to think about it and said “Okay, you still have to meet with her and tell her there’s been a three-month extension and some of the issues we’ve noticed.”

I had that meeting and the person saw the writing on the wall and left before that extension was up (this was in one of our bigger communities with lots of options for alternate employment.)

And another future blog post I could write is on the subject of unintended consequences – financial and otherwise – of certain decisions that seem straight forward on the surface but end up having deeper reverberations.

In this case, we struggled to recruit anyone to replace this employee requiring me to go out and spend a week covering the branch with no one else willing and able to do it – in the community (often local board members could fill in) or at HQ.  That pulled me away from my own work.

My memory is that other branch librarians started asking questions about why this person had left since many had met her at our bi-annual staff development day and recognized her as having some unique qualities even among our wider branch staff – in particular, her youth and tech-savviness stood out.

Anyhow, the story has a happy ending.  After finishing their schooling, this  person is still employed in libraries to this day – working in a city library instead of a small town and being in a unionized environment which helps clarify some of the issues she had with the “flexbility” of working in a small town, non-unionized role.

(I mean, I did 10 years in non-unionized non-profits and had very little issue of this kind myself.  Other than pay being shite, it wasn’t honestly much different than my experiences in unionized environments where a lot of your experience comes down to whether you have kind, understanding bosses or not.)

I would think that it’s obvious that you want people who bring good ideas and skills to their role even if they are outspoken “troublemakers” instead of people who are simply crappy at their jobs but may be quiet or not make waves in any way.

But I could also be a bit biased in that regard… 😉

Share this post

Facebook
X
Threads
Reddit
Email
Print

About Head Tale

I started this blog in 2006 when I was doing my Master of Library Science degree at the University of Western Ontario.

Post a Comment

About Head Tale

I started this blog in 2006 when I was doing my Master of Library Science degree at the University of Western Ontario.

6,930 posts and 3,356 comments since 2006.

Topics

Categories

Monthly Archives

Archives