Saw that long-time FIMS prof, Bernd Frohmann has passed away and though I never had a class with him, I definitely had some memorable interactions with him.

It began when he was one of the few (only?) profs to come to the Spirit of Librarianship Award presenation at the Grad Club and I’ve always appreciated people who show a curiosity and an engagement with what’s going on. I think of a current manager at RPL who sought me out at a conference years ago just because she heard I had the unique position of “Organization Development Specialist” and wanted to know more about what that was (I wish I knew so I could’ve told her!) 😉

What I didn’t know was Frohmann was also a strong union activist for the professors at FIMS and, somewhat ironic, that’s what caused something we were involved in to spiral into a huge ball of chaos (Twenty years later, I haven’t changed much.)

What happened was I was the Academic Rep on our Student Council (ha ha – apparently they didn’t check your marks before electing you) and I wanted to update and revise the “Mid-Term Evaluations” process that was separate from the official performance review process professors underwent but was a thing where the Student Council came into classrooms mid-way through each semester and basically did a simple survey of how it was going without the professor present.

I wanted to update the process and make it have more usefulness so I wrote up a proposal where we’d do a written survey, compile the results and oh, I’d meet with the Dean to discuss where there were issues.
I had talked to the Dean about the idea who was open to it and our Council Exec (including the President) who really liked it. But once I sent out my email to share the new process with students and faculty, Frohmann reacted in a *very* aggressive way, sending a reply to all recipients saying this process violated the collective agreement, recommending professors not partake and I think even calling the Dean out for her openness, if not full embracement, of the idea.
YIKES!
Here is one of his earliest emails in response to my proposal:
Bernd Frohmann wrote:
Hello Jason,
The student council does nor have the authority to compel any faculty member to participate in this process. Only the Employer can assign duties.
Bernd Frohmann
So here I was doing something I think is just to benefit students (and hopefully profs too – I mean, we had one who fell asleep in class every time a student did a presentation so yeah, there were issues that needed addressed that the FIMS faculty union, would likely approach as defending the person with the issue – which is absolutely what they should do – whereas I saw our process as a method to address these things.) I got feedback from all sides – our President was still supportive as were a couple profs who wrote me directly. Here’s a sample:
Jason
I just want to say first and foremost, that I’m sure your nerves are frayed with this ongoing back and forth concerning the mid-term evaluations (oh crap, I meant to say “mid-term feedback sessions that in no way are a means of impacting employer/employee contractual obligations”).
I also wanted to indicate that I have absolutely no problem of a feedback, evaluation, whatever being conducted in my class. I realize that my outlook might be entirely different – I’m not a full time employed individual of the university. I teach, because I enjoy it, and it keeps me in touch with what’s going on in the library world. To be honest, I find in some situations, that I’m walking out of a class with more knowledge than I’m putting into it. This feedback is a useful tool for me to improve the experience. I’ve been where you are sitting, and I have had to deal with some nasty courses – I also know, that doesn’t mean that the feedback should be seen as a written in stone demand to change, but at least comment to reflect upon.
Anywho (sic) (sic) (sic), just figured I would throw my two cents at you. Hopefully, it didn’t bean you in the head.
Cheers
Rob
I even had similar responses from brand-new faculty (are PhD students teaching a class “faculty”) who I suspected might get a rough evaluation based on their struggles, not due to lack of knowledge or ability but just being new to their role:
Hi Jason,
Although I still have concerns related to this new feedback process – unrelated to the various e-mails- I will give this session a chance. I’m opting in. – Jen

My memory is that I got a mix of profs opting in or out (which was always embedded into the process). I also got clarification from one prof that the process I was modifying didn’t exist (which begs the question – why did our Dean and the Faculty Union rep not make this point into account account when I made my proposal as a guy in my third and final semester of the program?)
Of course, there has never actually been any such thing as a “mid-term evaluation” of instructors or courses in the MLIS program. This term is a misnomer which keeps reincarnating itself, in spite of repeated corrections in the past. The process is properly referred to as “feedback” and was intended to alert faculty members to possible problems with specific course offerings which they might be able to address in the remaining period before the end of term. – Tim
So anyhow, imagine this back and forth but times a million emails involving profs, students, student council, administration and so on.

One memorable response I had was from the Faculty of Information and Media Studies (FIMS) Dean, Gloria Leckie, writing to tell me I “needed to learn a lot about labour relations” which is especially funny given a) her not recognizing the red flags this might create in a unionized workplace and shutting down this idea when proposed and b) given my union and political involvement since, yeah, still learning, Dean!) 😉

Anyhow, having just seen Jimmy Carr last night (uhm, later this week as I’m totally not backdating this post on Saturday night), I will say this: Frohmann’s dead so my condolences. Also fuck that guy.
The tribute I link to above makes references to him being a bit of an ornery personality in general:
The particularity of that taste was emblematic of his absolute commitment to precision, and of the clarity of his sensibilities. This made him a difficult colleague and teacher at times, and all of us felt his prickliness in various ways. He was a complicated guy — son of Silesian refugees; philosopher of Wittgenstein teaching in a professional librarianship program; promiscuous intellect and reader with an iron editorial fist (the “Frohmann filter,” we called it); warm and gracious friend with a staunch allergy to sentimentality. None of us had a frictionless experience with Bernie. It simply wasn’t possible.
The irony is that this tribute also makes me wish I’d actually gotten to know him in friendly terms as he seemed like a guy I’d get along with.
Anyhow, that’s a LONG preamble to the point of this post – one of the many koans I have in life is that “Everything you do matters; nothing you do matters.” What I mean by this is that you never know when some small action – helping a child find a book they want, helping a stranger whose car has broken down, choosing to try to improve something you think could be better – even if it blows up in your face – is important.
But rarely are any of these things that matter in the long-term – I have no idea if FIMS Student Council still does “mid-term evaluation feedback check-in but not official so help me gosh” sessions (thanks Rob – you were a great prof!) – but I doubt anything Frohmann and me and everyone got caught up in really mattered.
That person with the broken down car you helped may always remember your kindness and maybe even pay it forward but you might forget about it by the next day. That kid you find a book for might just enjoy the book. Or they might go on to be a challenging, activist professor who studied with Marshall McLuhan and influenced a whole range of students and future scholars.
I have no idea what Frohmann looks like deceased (more Jimmy Carr influence) but I think at the end of the day – “be good, be kind and leave a beautiful corpse” is a good way to live our time on earth.
