The branch I work at is the newest in the Regina Public Library system. Since it opened just about two years ago it has had the following two pieces of art hanging in the YA area…
These pieces have provoked a mixed reaction to say the least.
Some staff and patrons felt that these pieces were depressing and dark, reinforcing the worst stereotypes of young people. (“Oh, the world is dark/Black/All around/Death.”) One person I know referred to them as the “Concentration Camp Kids”. Another staff member from Central told me: “If you do nothing else at Regent beyond getting that art removed, you’ll have been successful!” 😉
Of course, others thought the art was very appropriate for the YA area. Our branch is in an area where there are many disadvantaged youth so it was felt that this art could help young people who are dealing with tough circumstances, depression or who knows what else, to be able to see themselves reflected in the art and gain a sense that they weren’t alone and that there were others who felt the way they did.
It’s a legitimate point and I can see both sides of the issue. But personally, I come at it from a strong belief that the library should be a warm, inviting place; a refuge from the everyday struggles of many people (of all backgrounds) and perhaps even a place where people find joy, happiness and fun.
There are many ways we create that environment – the staff we hire, the programs we run, the services we offer and yes, the art we hang on the walls.
Fortunately, no matter what side of the issue you’re on, the art was due for a refresh now that we’ve been open for a couple years. RPL’s Dunlop Art Gallery was undertaking a system-wide art refresh across our branch network so I was able to arrange to have three pieces installed that are diametrically opposed to what we had before – the new pieces are light, colourful, playful, and an embodiment of youth mash-up culture. And I was able to jump to the front of the line to have it done too! 😉
Staff from RPL’s Dunlop Art Gallery were out today to install those pieces. Time will tell what reaction they provoke (my main concern is that this art might be a bit *too* childish for a YA area. But then again, comics are popular with people of all ages so who knows?)
The new art also gave us an excuse to re-arrange our furnishings in the YA area as well so that will also be interesting to watch to see if the new layout changes how people use the space. At any rate, it was very rewarding to see a patron sitting on the couch this afternoon, using his laptop on the little table in front of him.
